Why Lidl are not nuts

Lidl has recalled some batches of their Alesto Honey Peanuts because the word ‘peanuts’ does not appear on the label, as is required by Law.

This echoes a recall of over three years ago by Booths, who withdrew some peanut products labelled ‘monkey nuts’ rather than ‘peanuts’ – a recall which was widely criticised, including by then RCGP chair Clare Gerada, but which, like this one, was absolutely correct, and which I defended here.

In the Lidl case, the word for peanut only appeared in Spanish and Portuguese, but not English. Nevertheless, Clause 30 from the FSA Guidance on Allergen and Miscellaneous Labelling Provisions is worth quoting once again as it still applies:

Whilst these may also be commonly referred to as ground nuts or monkey nuts, the term “peanuts” [their emphasis] should be used for allergen labelling purposes

Not unexpectedly, some casual observers and commentators are ridiculing the decision on social media. I’m surprised the Sun didn’t have more fun with it, but perhaps they were unaware these were EU laws they could have gleefully trashed.

I’m repeating myself, but allergen labelling laws are there to protect consumers and to save lives. They must be stuck to by the letter, for any relaxation of the rules undermines the rules, and from there it’s a slippery slope downwards towards confusion and inconsistency and health risk.

The rule is ‘peanut(s)’ must appear on labels. If you think it’s silly to abide by this rule, then I’d be very interested to hear what you think the alternative rule should be? “‘Peanuts’ should appear on labels unless there’s a nice picture of them on the front”? 

An adult peanut allergic, long used to managing their condition, would be unlikely to make a mistake with the Lidl product, but what about a foreigner? What about a well-meaning relative of a peanut allergic child? Again, an error is unlikely, but not impossible, though a bigger problem in this case is that the product may contain traces of tree nuts – a fact which also does not appear in English. We cannot take chances.

Although there have arguably been too many allergen recalls this year (see here, including another Lidl one concerning a yogurt failing to mention ‘milk’ on the label), one such as this does offer continuing reassurance to the food allergic community that manufacturers, supermarkets and the FSA are on the ball regarding the issue.

Although there may well be room for improvement, the rules are in decent health, and appear to be working well. We should be pleased about this, not sneery, nor mocking, nor sarcastic.

2 Comments

  1. Marcus Trelle

    So supermarkets are required to list information that is not true? Peanuts are not nuts, they are legumes. The only thing they should be required to say is that they may cause allergies. They should not have to say that they contain nuts when they actually don’t. Also, I have noticed that canned fish says that it contains fish. Are they really legally required to state an obvious fact? Again, may cause allergies is enough and less stupid.

    Reply
    1. Alex G (Post author)

      I think you’ve misread or misinterpreted the article. The title is a pun — why Lidl are not nuts ie ‘not mad’.
      This is nothing to do with nuts. Products containing peanuts should state they contain ‘peanuts’. This didn’t. So Lidl withdrew it – and rightly so.
      All foods may cause allergies so that would be an unhelpful statement to make.
      I think single-ingredient products which are allergens are required to make ‘contains’ statement when the name of the product does not specify the name of the allergen. So a packet of tuna may say ‘tuna’ on the front, but have to say ‘contains fish’ on the back because ‘fish’ is the name of the allergen which should appear according to EU regulation.

      Reply

Leave a Reply to Marcus Trelle Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. Please read our Privacy Policy and our Affiliates Disclosure in 'About' more information

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this.

Close